The Center for Studying Health System Change

HomeAbout HSCPublicationsNews RoomConferencesLinksLinks

Sign up for HSC Alerts!

Policy Research
Insurance Coverage
Access to Care
Managed Care and Markets
-Consumer Experience
-Health Plans
-Hospitals and Physicians

Issue Briefs
Community Reports
Tracking Reports
Data Bulletins
Journal Articles
Other Publications

CTS Data
CTS Surveys
CTS Site Visits
Data Files
Design and Methods

Sign up for HSC Alerts
News Media

Email This Document


Changes in Hospital Competitive Strategy: A New Medical Arms Race?

Feb. 21, 2003
Health Services Research, 38:1, Part II (February 2003), pp. 447-469
Kelly Devers, Linda R. Brewster, Lawrence P. Casalino

Hospitals' strategic emphasis changed significantly between 1996-1997 and 2000-2001. In the mid-1990s, hospitals primarily competed on price through "wholesale" strategies (i.e., providing services attractive to managed care plans). By 2000-2001, nonprice competition was becoming increasingly important and hospitals were reviving "retail" strategies (i.e., providing services attractive to individual physicians and the patients they serve). Three major factors explain this shift in hospital strategy: less than anticipated selective contracting and capitated payment; the freeing up of hospital resources previously devoted to horizontal and vertical integration strategies; and, the emergence and growth of new competitors.

Renewed emphasis on nonprice competition and retail strategies, and the service mimicking and one-upmanship that result, suggest that a new medical arms race is emerging. However, there are important differences between the medical arms race today and the one that occurred in the 1970s and early 1980s: the hospital market is more concentrated and price competition remains relatively important. The development of a new medical arms race has significant research and policy implications.

Click here for a PDF of the article.

Printable Version

pdf Download


Linda R. Brewster


Lawrence P. Casalino


Kelly Devers


Back to Top
Simple Search

Site Last Updated: 10/23/2006           Privacy Policy
Center for Studying Health System Change
600 Maryland Ave, SW #550
Washington, DC 20024
tel: 202.484.5261
fax: 202.484.9258
[email protected]